Serving Dallas–Fort Worth and surrounding communitiesLet’s talk: (945) 300-9018
G3 Roofing & Construction LogoG3 KNOWSGET IN THE KNOW
← Get in the Know

Roofing & Storm Damage

Roof Claim Closed Without Payment? Lessons From Oklahoma

Aerial view of a storm-damaged home with debris piled along the driveway after the Sanger tornado, from a G3 Knows video - G3 Knows
Roof Denied Chapter 1: Harvey video thumbnail - G3 KnowsWatchRoof Denied Chapter 1: Harvey
Watch: Roof Denied Chapter 1: Harvey

If your roof claim was closed without payment, you've probably wondered whether that was really the end of it. Right next door in Oklahoma, the state just answered that question for a whole lot of homeowners.

According to the Oklahoma Insurance Department, a market conduct examination found that State Farm Fire and Casualty "improperly denied or failed to pay for roof damage and necessary repairs" on wind and hail claims from Oklahoma homeowners. State Farm agreed to a settlement of more than $45 million. That includes at least $35 million set aside for affected consumers, $10 million for the state's Strengthen Oklahoma Homes program and $2.86 million in fines and exam costs. The Associated Press reported the settlement too.

This is a serious one. So let's get in the know about what happened and what it means for us in North Texas.

What Happened in Oklahoma?

The department says eligible Oklahoma homeowners with a wind or hail claim from January 1, 2021, through December 31, 2025, that was closed without payment will get another chance to have it reviewed. That includes some claims that were only partially paid. An independent third-party claims administrator, picked by the department and State Farm together, will look at the original claim file plus any additional documentation the homeowner sends in.

Here's the part that jumped out at me. The commissioner said the department put independent engineers in the field to inspect roofs, something he said no other state had done in a traditional examination. In other words, somebody actually went up and looked.

State Farm will mail department-approved notices to eligible homeowners explaining how to opt in.

Does This Apply to Texas Homeowners?

No. This settlement is for eligible Oklahoma policyholders only. If you're in Texas, it doesn't reopen your claim.

But Texas is hail country too, and the lesson travels. A closed claim file is only as good as what's in it. When the damage on the roof and the paperwork don't match, the paperwork usually wins. That's why what gets documented, and how, matters so much.

Why Does Documentation Decide So Much?

That Oklahoma review looks at the claim file and whatever the homeowner adds. If your file is a couple of blurry phone pictures from the driveway, there isn't much to review.

Good documentation looks like this:

  • Photos and video of every slope, plus close-ups of hits on shingles, ridge caps, vents and flashings
  • Gutters, downspouts, screens, siding, fences and outdoor equipment, because hail rarely hits just the roof
  • Inside the house, like attic stains, ceiling spots and wet insulation
  • Measurements and a written scope of what it actually takes to put the roof back right

Take lots of video. For the full checklist, read how to document roof damage for your insurance claim, and if you're not sure what hail looks like up close, here's how to tell if your roof has hail damage.

What Can Texas Homeowners Do If a Claim Was Closed?

I'm a contractor, not your lawyer and not your adjuster, so I won't tell you what your policy covers. Here's what I'd want any friend of mine to know:

  1. Get it in writing. Ask your insurance company for the written reason your claim was closed or what was and wasn't paid.
  2. Read your policy. Look for deadlines and conditions. Your agent can walk you through it.
  3. Get the roof looked at again. A thorough inspection with photos, video and measurements shows what's really up there today.
  4. Know who can help. The Texas Department of Insurance has a help line at 800-252-3439 and a page on how to get help with an insurance complaint. You can also talk with a licensed public adjuster or an attorney about your options.
  5. Protect the house in the meantime. A small leak left alone turns into a big one. Here's what to do about a roof leak tonight.

We go deeper on next steps in roof claim denied? what homeowners should know next.

What About Stronger Roofs?

Part of the settlement goes to Strengthen Oklahoma Homes, which helps eligible Oklahomans install fortified roofs. The department reports an average premium savings of $700 for participants there. That's an Oklahoma number, not a Texas promise. If you're curious about building to the FORTIFIED standard here, start with IBHS's FORTIFIED Roof page and ask your agent what your company offers.

Where Does G3 Fit?

G3 is your contractor. We inspect the whole roof and exterior, document it with photos, video and measurements, write the scope in Xactimate and rebuild it right. We don't negotiate or adjust claims. What we do is make sure what's on your roof is clearly shown, so you and whoever you're working with have the facts. Every job carries our 1-year workmanship warranty. Learn more on our roofing and storm damage page.

Watch: Roof Denied Chapter 1

The video on this page is the first chapter of our Roof Denied series. It's a real look at why the details on a roof matter so much.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the Oklahoma State Farm settlement apply in Texas?

No. The Oklahoma Insurance Department says it covers eligible Oklahoma homeowners with wind or hail claims from 2021 through 2025 that were closed without payment.

Who can I call in Texas with an insurance complaint?

The Texas Department of Insurance help line is 800-252-3439, and TDI has an online complaint process.

Can a contractor reopen my claim?

No. G3 inspects, documents and rebuilds. Questions about your claim go to your insurance company, your agent, a licensed public adjuster or an attorney.

We're based in Argyle, TX, and we'd rather you understand your roof than guess about it. Tell us what's happening, and we'll help you understand your next step. NOT SURE WHAT'S REALLY ON YOUR ROOF? CALL G3 AT (945) 300-9018.

Know Your Next Step

Tell Us What's Happening.

We'll help you understand how G3 can help. Call (945) 300-9018 or use the button below.

SCHEDULE AN INSPECTION